79 North Midway Road , Shelter Island, NY 11964 - Suffolk County

Set down a long driveway leading to a private oasis, Fox Hollow Farm is an English-style manor built in 1897 with thoughtful additions, blending design, charm, and timeless style. The 5,350 sq ft main house features 6 bedrooms, 2 spacious living rooms, a TV room, library/office, games room, and eat-in kitchen, with wide plank floors and multiple doors and picture windows opening to stunning views of the English garden, paddocks and rolling land, with ample room for tennis. Mature plantings include Copper Beech, Crepe Myrtles, Hydrangeas, and beach grasses, supported by a full irrigation system. A 3-car garage adjoins a 2-story, 2-bedroom guest house with a deck overlooking a very private free-form pool area. The estate also boasts a stunning barn with 3 stalls, center aisle, tack room, wash stall, and a second-floor hayloft with 15 ft ceilings, maintaining the property's rare equestrian legacy. Impossible to recreate and unimaginable not to fall in love with, Fox Hollow Farm offers the perfect blend of Shelter Island history, pastoral beauty, and modern comfort. The estate carries a remarkable creative pedigree: Raul Martinez, Global Creative Director of Vogue, where he oversees creative direction across all titles and platforms, and Alex Gonzalez, co-founder of AR New York and formerly creative director at L'Uomo Vogue, GQ, and consulting creative director of W magazine. Their vision and aesthetic sensibility are reflected throughout the property, adding rare distinction to this Shelter Island gem. Horses depicted are artistic renderings.