Property
$135,00016 Acres
For Sale
For Sale
$135,00016 Acres
For Sale

0WP Piety Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Static Google Map
Property ID 25599956

Private Off-Grid Camp With 2 Ponds Close To Amenities

What a great opportunity to purchase a very affordable hunting or vacation getaway spot with a cabin and two ponds, located in an area renowned for its wildlife conservation. This camp is located at almost the highest elevation on the ridge and offers beautiful views of the Valleyan ideal spot for whitetail deer and wild turkey, with lots of sign present. In fact, with its surrounding wooded areas, farms, and conservation-managed state lands, wildlife thrives in this region. The camp has recently had a new roof installed and features three bedrooms and a bathroom that is used by collecting rain water. One natural pond and one man-made pond (20 plus feet deep) are located for both recreational purposes, as well as a beautiful view. For even more outdoor recreation beyond this base camp, the property is only 3.5 miles from another 1835 acres of NYS public lands with Pitcher Springs State Forest, providing access to additional outdoor recreational activities such as hunting, fishing, hiking and primitive camping, while Taylor Valley State Forest is only 5 miles the other direction and offers 4638 acres for more outdoor enjoyment, hunting, snowmobiling, hiking on 9 miles of the Finger Lakes Trail that passes through the State Forest, as well as camping and a picnic/day use area. The renowned Otselic River is literally a few miles down the road from this property and offers excellent fishing for brown trout, brook trout, smallmouth bass, and walleye, among other species. Winter sports in this area include snowmobiling on the many state & local trail systems nearby, as well as downhill skiing & snowboarding in the winter at the Greek Peak Mountain Resort, only 21 miles away, while in the summer, zip lining, Sky Tours & mountain coaster rides are available as well. In addition, Dorchester Park and the Whitney Point Reservoir are 20 minutes away and offer a 1,200-acre lake renowned for walleye, bass, perch, and crappie fishing, a public beach, picnic areas, and a boat launch. Amenities and shopping are available in Cincinnatus, only a mile away. More shopping, restaurants & entertainment are available in Cortland, 25 minutes away & Binghamton in less than 45 minutes. New York City/George Washington Bridge is 3.5 hours away.

From elevation to risk assessment

Search for detailed parcel information including; Elevation & Vegetation Maps, Ownership Information, Detailed Parcel Information, Crop History Map, Soil Survey Productivity Data, and more.

Research Parcel Information

Directions

CortlandNew York 13045Head south on Main St toward Orchard St0.2 miTurn left onto Port Watson St1.2 miContinue onto NY-41 S/US-11 S Continue to follow NY-41 S7.4 miSlight left onto Telephone Rd7.6 miSharp right onto Piety Hill Rd Destination will be on the left0.4 mi5530 Piety Hill RdCincinnatus, NY 13040

Resources

Links
Property Website
Contact Seller
Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Plymouth, NY

(607) 220-6247
Listing provided by
Josh Buell
Whitetail Properties Real Estate(607) 220-6247
Source: MLS# 11608813
Listing last updated: November 19, 2025 at 9:58 PM
Report this listing

Josh Buell

Whitetail Properties Real Estate
View Phone Number

Message
Josh Buell

Josh Buell

Whitetail Properties Real Estate